Current:Home > ScamsFederal appeals court expands limits on Biden administration in First Amendment case-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Federal appeals court expands limits on Biden administration in First Amendment case
View Date:2025-01-14 18:42:23
The nation’s top cybersecurity defense agency likely violated the First Amendment when lobbying Silicon Valley companies to remove or suppress the spread of online content about elections, a federal appeals court ruled Tuesday.
The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals expanded an injunction issued in September to include the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, ruling that it used frequent interactions with social media platforms “to push them to adopt more restrictive policies on election-related speech.”
The previous decision from a panel of three judges – nominated by Republican presidents – concluded that the actions of the Biden White House, FBI and other government agencies likely violated the First Amendment but that CISA – which is charged with securing elections from online threats – attempted to convince, not coerce.
Republican attorneys general, who brought the case, asked for a rehearing. In Tuesday’s order, the 5th Circuit judges ruled that CISA facilitated the FBI’s interactions with social media companies.
The order bars CISA and top agency officials including director Jen Easterly from taking steps to “coerce or significantly encourage” tech companies to take down or curtail the spread of social media posts.
The Justice Department declined to comment. CISA, which is part of the Department of Homeland Security, said it does not comment on ongoing litigation, but executive director Brandon Wales said in a statement that the agency does not censor speech or facilitate censorship.
The lawsuit was filed by the attorneys general of Missouri and Louisiana as well as individuals who said their speech was censored.
“CISA is the ‘nerve center’ of the vast censorship enterprise, the very entity that worked with the FBI to silence the Hunter Biden laptop story,” Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey tweeted.
Born of conservative frustration with social media moderation practices, the lawsuit is one of a growing number that accuse government officials of colluding with platforms to favor Democrats and the Biden administration.
The ruling queues the case up for the Supreme Court, adding yet another high-profile and controversial social media case to the court’s docket. The Biden administration had already filed an emergency appeal in the case, but that effort was suspended when the 5th Circuit agreed to rehear the matter.
“We look forward to defending your First Amendment rights at the nation’s highest court,” Bailey tweeted.
The appeals court stayed the effects of its ruling for 10 days, which will give the Biden administration time to update their request to the Supreme Court.
The high court will hear arguments later this month in a pair of challenges dealing with whether public officials may block constituents on social media.
Separately, the justices agreed last week to decide two suits challenging laws in Texas and Florida that would limit the ability of platforms like Facebook, YouTube and X to moderate content. The state laws at issue in the cases, both of which have been temporarily blocked by federal courts, severely limit the ability of social media companies to kick users off their platforms or remove individual posts.
veryGood! (2846)
Related
- Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul stirs debate: Is this a legitimate fight?
- U.S. military Osprey aircraft crashes into ocean off Japan's coast killing at least 1, official says
- Congress is eying immigration limits as GOP demands border changes in swap for Biden overseas aid
- France arrests yoga guru Gregorian Bivolaru on suspicion of indoctrinating followers for sexual exploitation
- Bradley Cooper and Gigi Hadid Enjoy a Broadway Date Night and All that Jazz
- Proposed NewRange copper-nickel mine in Minnesota suffers fresh setback on top of years of delays
- What works for treating the common cold? Many doctors say 'not much'
- Fast-track legislative maneuvers hinder public participation, nonpartisan Kentucky group says
- Trump ally Steve Bannon blasts ‘lawfare’ as he faces New York trial after federal prison stint
- Study says the US is ill-prepared to ensure housing for the growing number of older people
Ranking
- Certifying this year’s presidential results begins quietly, in contrast to the 2020 election
- Oklahoma prepares to execute man for 2001 double slaying despite self-defense claim
- Agency urges EBT cardholders to change PINs after skimming devices were found statewide
- Consumer Reports pummels EV reliability, says hybrids have significantly fewer problems
- Bill on school bathroom use by transgender students clears Ohio Legislature, heads to governor
- Algeria passes law to protect media freedom. Others used to imprison journalists remain on the books
- MLS, EPL could introduce 'sin bins' to punish players, extend VAR involvement
- China says US arms sales to Taiwan are turning the island into a ‘powder keg’
Recommendation
-
Oklahoma school district adding anti-harassment policies after nonbinary teen’s death
-
In Netflix's 'American Symphony,' Jon Batiste, wife Suleika Jaouad share joy and pain
-
Former federal prison lieutenant sentenced to 3 years for failing to help sick inmate who later died
-
Residents in St. Croix sue government over water contaminated with lead and copper
-
John Robinson, former USC Trojans and Los Angeles Rams coach, dies at 89
-
Stock market today: Asian shares mostly higher ahead of US price update, OPEC+ meeting
-
College football playoff rankings: Georgia keeps No. 1 spot, while top five gets shuffled
-
Hurricane-Weary Floridians Ask: What U.N. Climate Talks?